Treaty Body Litigation Initiative
In 2021 the Clinic launched the Treaty Body Litigation Initiative to bring or support individual claims before the key monitoring bodies of the UN system, to seek meaningful redress for victims of digital rights violations, and advocate for a rights-respecting jurisprudence touching on some of the most important issues of human rights in the digital age. Today’s treaty body jurisprudence is in its earliest phase of development. This project aim to help develop that jurisprudence through strategic use of the individual complaints procedures, collaborating especially (though not solely) with civil society actors in national environments least likely to provide remedies that meet international standards.
Despite the significance of the treaty body system, civil society organizations have not devoted a broad and sustained effort to help shape its jurisprudence with an eye to reinforcing the past decade of innovations in digital rights by the UN’s political bodies. NGOs around the complex UN human rights system have focused, with good reason, on advocacy before bodies such as the Human Rights Council and its Special Procedures and Universal Periodic Review, to great benefit for digital rights. Others have focused on the regional systems, using the progressive stands taken by UN actors to formulate, negotiate and advocate for new or strengthened norms within the European, African and Inter-American systems. The Treaty Body Litigation Initiative aims to work with partners globally, especially in the Global South, to identify cases ripe for treaty body consideration and most likely to advance the jurisprudence of digital rights.
This project is lead by Clinic Director David Kaye and Hinako Sugiyama.
Recent updates related to this area of focus can be found here.
Featured Publications
Amicus Briefs
- Case: Black Case No. Aor 3011/2561, Aor 3054/2561 and Red Case No. Aor 1128/2563, Aor 1129/2563
Date: April 2023
Court: Thai Constitutional Court
Amicus Brief
- Case: A case litigating against the constitutionality of Article 20.3.3 of the code of administrative offense, which bans public actions aimed at discrediting the use of the armed forces
Date: April 2023
Court: Russian Constitutional Court
Amicus Brief
- Case: Gonzalez v. Google LLC
Date: January 19, 2023
Court: Supreme Court of the United States
Amicus Brief - Case: Macaté v. Lithuania
Date: April 2023
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Amicus Brief - Case: NSO Group Technologies LTD.Et al., v. WhatsApp Inc. Et al
Date: December 23, 2020
Court: US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Amicus Brief
- Case: Alessandro Biancardi v. Italy, Application no. 77419/16
Date: July 30, 2020
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Amicus Brief
Motion for leave to file brief amicus curiae
- Case: Amnesty International Togo et al. v. Togo, ECW/CCJ/APP/61/18
Date: January 27, 2020
Court: Community Court of Justice of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS)
Amicus Brief as filed
Motion for leave to file Amicus Brief
Court Judgment
- Case: Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. v. Turkey, Application no. 25479/19
Date: November 27, 2019
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Amicus Brief as filed
Application for leave to file brief amicus curiae
- Case: Privacy International and Others v. United Kingdom, Application no. 46259/16
Date: September 16, 2019
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Intervention as filed
Court Judgment
- Case: Big Brother Watch and Others v. United Kingdom, Application nos. 58170/13, 62322/14 and 24960/15
Date: June 3, 2019
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Intervention as filed
Court Judgement
- Case(s): OOO Flavus v. Russia, Application no. 12468/15 and four related Applications (nos. 20159/15, 23489/15, 19074/16 and 61919/16)
Date: 21 September 2018
Court: European Court of Human Rights
Intervention as filed
Court Judgment
- Case: Application No. 2016Heonma388
Date: May 9, 2017
Court: Constitutional Court of the Republic of Korea
Third party intervention submission as filed (English)
Third party intervention submission as filed (Korean)
- Case: Kidane v. Ethiopia
Date: Oct 31, 2016
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
Brief of UN Special Rapporteurs on freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and association, and the situation of human rights defenders as filed
Motion for leave to file brief amici curiae as filed
Thematic Reports
- The Clinic provided support to the UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Opinion and Expression (2014-2020) by conducting research and drafting for the following thematic reports, related to digital rights and intermediary accountability:
- Freedom of Expression and Oversight in Online Content Moderation (2020)
View Research report
- Online hate speech (2019)
A/74/486
View report page
- Surveillance and human rights (2019)
A/HRC/41/35
View report page
Overview of submissions received
A/HRC/41/35/Add.3
Summary of an expert’s consultation
A/HRC/41/35/Add.4
- Artificial Intelligence technologies and implications for the information environment (2018)
A/73/348
View report page
- Online content regulation (2018)
A/HRC/38/35
View report page
Supplementary annex accompanying the thematic report
A/HRC/38/35/Add.1
- The role of digital access providers (2017)
A/HRC/35/22
View report page
Supplementary material accompanying the thematic report
A/HRC/35/22/Add.4
- Freedom of expression, states and the private sector in the digital age (2016)
A/HRC/32/38
View report page
States and civil society submissions
- The use of encryption and anonymity to exercise the rights to freedom of opinion and expression in the digital age (2015)
A/HRC/29/32
View report page
States and civil society submissions